Chair’s Column (Winter 2026)

[2026] 3 FRJ 183. The Chair considers Financial Remedies reform, excessive costs and HHJ Stuart Farquahar's retirement, remembers the late Sir James Munby and HHJ Clive Million, and announces the winners of the FRJ essay competition.

The FRJ Financial Remedies Reform Corner

Along with many other individuals and organisations, I spent a chunk of the summer working on responses to the government’s important consultation paper ‘A Fairer End to Relationships’, the deadline for responses being 14 August 2026. The huge interest in this topic is fully reflected in the FRJ’s ‘FR Reform Corner’ on our website. Here we have gathered together a collection of excellent papers inspired by the consultation paper, and a wide range of views are expressed on the general principles and the finer details engaged by the proposals, including weighty contributions from Professor David Hodson, Baroness Deech and Dr Anna Heenan. I understand the government has received overall about 3,500 responses from interested parties and, with a change of responsible minister in the summer 2026 government re-shuffle, it is reasonable to expect a fairly long lead time to the announcement of concrete decisions. In my own paper I welcomed the introduction of long-awaited redistributive remedies for former cohabitants, but focused on the resource issues involved for the Financial Remedies Court (FRC) and, whatever decisions are made, it is important for the government to provide proper and adequate resources to fund the administrative and judicial resources to make sure they can work properly.

The late Sir James Munby and ‘The Astonishing Fate of Scott v Scott (1911–1913)’

On 6 October 2026, a packed Temple Church celebrated the admirable life of Sir James Munby, who died on 1 January 2026. Among the eulogies was a powerful and funny contribution from Sir Nicholas Mostyn, and he drew attention to what may be the last work from the pen of the late and great former President on the subject of transparency in the FRC – ‘The Astonishing Fate of Scott v Scott (1911–1913)’. The powerful 92-page treatise by Sir James Munby has been published posthumously with the assistance of Sir Nicholas Mostyn and now finds its public space on the FRJ Blog page for 1 October 2026. This is a timely intervention as the Court of Appeal will be considering the important and controversial issues of transparency and anonymity at a hearing in November 2026.

The ongoing problem of excessive costs spending

This column has previously raised the issue of excessive costs spending in financial remedies proceedings and I remain very conscious that we seem a long way away from finding an effective solution. The government’s financial remedy reforms don’t really address the issues. It is important, therefore, that the FRJ continues to provide a forum for lively discussion of this issue. In this issue we present two persuasive articles on the subject to contribute to the debate. First, ‘Costs in Financial Remedy Proceedings: Time for Greater Discipline?’ by District Judge Peter Hatvany. Second, ‘The Case for Calderbank: A Procedural Reform Too Far?’ by Tom Quinn and Francesca Skakel from Birketts Solicitors. They are both well worth a read.

The retirement of HHJ Stuart Farquhar

I was sad to receive the news early this year of the imminent retirement of Stuart Farquhar from the Circuit Bench and from his position as Lead Judge of the Kent, Surrey and Sussex FRC zone. Stuart has now departed and is (I trust) utilising his considerable judicial skills conducting private FDRs together with some sitting in retirement. I am pleased that in this issue’s interview, we have been able to capture some of his retirement thoughts, with most of which I very much agree. Stuart (as Lead Judge and as Chair of the very impressive Farquhar Committee) has been a considerable success and a major FRC figure of substance and his presence on the bench will be much missed. I will miss his presence also at FRC judicial events where his keen wit and sense of humour have always been much in evidence.

FRJ essay competition prize winners

Earlier this year the FRJ was pleased to run another essay competition for law students aspiring to a career in the world of financial remedies. Entrants were required to write 1,500 words on the topical subject: ‘To what extent should domestic abuse be taken into account in financial remedy proceedings?’. I was delighted to read the winning entries and to invite the two winners – Nia Brown and Molly Fay – to spend a court day with me in the summer in the Central Family Court. I was hugely impressed by their knowledge of and interest in the subject of financial remedies in general and wish them all the best for their future search for pupillage and beyond.

Farewell to HHJ Clive Million

The death of Clive Million in the summer at an all too young age was very rapid and shocking. He was a keen financial remedies specialist from his days as a District Judge at the Principal Registry of the Family Division (DJ PRFD) and an inspiring presence when I began my judicial days in that position (first as a deputy and later full-time). The rather unannounced disappearance of the PRFD in 2014 (a casualty of the invention of the single family court) caused a great deal of pain and sadness amongst those who worked in it and (it may not be widely known) the surviving individuals who held the position DJ PRFD meet to this day for an annual dinner, in part to lament the loss of this great institution. Clive’s always ebullient and entertaining presence at these gatherings will be much missed. I am pleased that we have been able to carry in this issue of the FRJ a tribute to Clive by (former Senior DJ PRFD and later HHJ) Philip Waller.

is curated by
The Leaders In Family Law Books & Software
EXPLORE OUR PRODUCTS